About two dozen MVNOs in the United States all have the same
dream - building a viable business around a targeted audience. There
are multiple MVNOs for teenagers, young adults, sports fans, prepaid
buyers, Hispanics, even small businesses. Carriers, including their
MVNOs, like to emphasize this kind of targeted marketing as
"personalization."
But personalization is driving a lot more than carrier business
in the industry. The movement, also called segmentation when it
comes to products and services, has caught fire among handset
manufacturers, application developers, content delivery companies
and billing and operations support systems (OSS) providers.
Many in the industry believe there will be a consolidation in the
MVNO business because there are too many targeting the same markets.
But segmentation isn't going to go away. The Danish research company
Strand Consult says the wireless industry has matured so much that
it is serving a disparate user group mandating different products
and services.
"Handset manufacturers and mobile operators can no longer survive
on the 'one size fits all' motto for mobile services and mobile
handsets," the consultancy says. "This is the reason why the players
in the mobile value chain are more or less forced to increasingly
use micro-segmentation."
Strand points out that Nokia launched 18 different handset models
in 1999. Last year the Finnish company had 41 new models, each
designed for a slightly different consumer. The consultancy says the
carriers and handset OEMs will target handset models for different
types of stores or in marketing different kinds of services.
SUB-BRANDING Wireless operators also are
segmenting their own businesses by launching their own sub-brands or
MVNOs. Strand says the South Korean carriers have been sub-branding
for years, mostly to generate higher data traffic with new brands.
Alan Pritchard, vice president of GSM/UMTS marketing for Nortel
Networks, says segmentation will increase as networks are developed
to enable more specialized content and applications. He says IP
multimedia subsystem (IMS) capabilities, which are starting to roll
out this year, are the key to delivering this kind of targeted
content.
"Ultimately," Pritchard says, "we're headed into very targeted
applications. IMS will allow application for very specific uses." He
suggests the possibility that an MVNO-like application could be set
up around one NFL football team, so there could be a service just
for Denver Broncos fans.
Analysts believe brand names are the best insurance for success
in the MVNO market, leveraging consumers' existing affinity. Where a
brand is recognized, new players are linking up with popular
Internet sites, such as the EarthLink-SK Telecom joint venture
Helio, set to launch this spring. Helio, which is targeting youths,
has linked up with the hottest Web community for young people,
MySpace, to offer MySpace Mobile.
Cingular also has a social networking service it calls "CoolTalk"
that uses technology from Canada's AirG. The service allows
subscribers to connect and chat in micro-communities for sports,
games and music, among other topics. Sprint has a similar service.
Cingular and Verizon Wireless also have linked up with the
California mobile community company Rabble, which aims at connecting
young people.
A Florida company, MSCorp, specializes in mobile content for the
Hispanic community in Latin America and the United States. It teamed
with Nokia on a project called Nokia Trends, linking mobile content
to music and multimedia festivals in Brazil, Colombia and
Argentina.
BILLING, OSS SUPPORT Deeper into the network,
companies that offer billing and OSS solutions for carriers also are
noticing the movement to segmentation and are starting to support
it.
Jeff Popoff, marketing vice president at Canada's Redknee, says
segmented services and the billing to go with them is a fact of life
as subscriber growth slows and revenue from voice services
stabilizes or declines.
"They've sold phones to anything that breathes," Popoff says,
particularly of European operators, where wireless penetration has
reached 100 percent or more in more than a dozen countries. "The
market is full and only the strongest will survive, which brings
about mergers and acquisitions."
Besides M&A, the only growth opportunity for carriers in
saturated markets will be by stealing customers from the
competition. That's done by segmented or targeted services, Popoff
says.
Examples of segmented services that Popoff points to include the
teen market and all that implies; an events-based segment focusing
on people who attend a sports contest or music festival with a
temporary pooling of all the phone numbers in that group; a loyalty
segment where frequent users of a specific service like MMS are
granted loyalty points leading to special offers; or a mobile PBX
system that adds mobile workers to a PBX for call routing. O2 in
Ireland offers the latter service, calling it Group Worker.
Redknee and other billing system vendors also offer payment
segmentation, allowing different pricing schemes for different
audiences. In Europe, carriers have 10 to 15 different billing
segments, Popoff says, targeting various things such as age,
ethnicity, SMS and e-mail.
Vodafone and O2 in Britain are using the Redknee IP Charging
Gateway for segmented services and content billing. They're using
the gateway for different pricing of such things as prepaid and
postpaid use of WAP, the Internet and MMS traffic, Popoff says.
On-portal content has one price and off-portal another.
Popoff says carrier sub-brands, also called house brands, will
start to arrive in North America in the next few years, rather than
a further proliferation of MVNOs. He says SK Telecom has about nine
different brands in Korea, while the KPN Group has a similar number
in some of the European countries where it has networks.
If Popoff is right, the U.S. market can expect a different kind
of brand bonanza in years to come.